Best Bar in Cape Coral, FL Nice Guys Pints & Pies

Chevre and toasted black sesame hush puppies served with hot honey.

Served with housemade herb butter, garlic & parm.

Served with chimichurri and sriracha crema

Includes black truffle honey mustard, chimichurri, house ketchup, citrus garlic aioli, sriracha crema, roasted garlic aioli.

Bite sized butter pretzels served with a charred jalapeño and cheese dip.

Served with black truffle honey mustard, ketchup.

House made with many cheeses.

Mixed greens with heart of palm, white balsamic dressing.

Small 12" | Medium 14" | Large 16"

Pepperoni, Housemade Sausage, Salami, Ham, Banana Pepper, Spinach, Jalapeno, Black Olive, Red Onion, Cremini Mushroom, Pineapple, Anchovy, Green Pepper, Garlic, Bacon, Caramelized Onion, Kalamata Olive, Ground Beef, Corn, Fried Chicken, Pulled Pork, Prosciutto, Gorgonzola, Black Garlic, Arugula, Egg, Chorizo, Calabrese, Heart of Palm, Artichoke, Mozzarella, Provolone, Feta, Cheddar, Pickle, Egg, Pinto Bean | Small | Medium | Large

Listed HOT to mellow

Super spicy (but flavorful).

Nickel city-style spicy.

Nice guy's house favorite! New Buffalo classic, sweet n' spicy.

Garlic herb butter with parmesan (with heat!).

Hot sauce with butter to mellow it out.

General Tso's sauce with garlic and pineapple.

Sweet n' tangy.

Black truffle oil, cremini mushroom, red onion, cheese, garlic, ground pepper, crisp sage • 12" | 14" | 16"

Hot honey, salami, prosciutto, garlic, tomato • 12" | 14" | 16"

Salami, calabrese, prosciutto, pepperoni, banana peppers, tomato, garlic, mozzarella, lettuce, onion, white balsamic, oregano • 12" | 14" | 16"

Corn, mozzarella, parmesan, white American, cilantro, citrus garlic aioli • 12" | 14" | 16"

All beef, special sauce, lettuce, cheese, pickle, onions, sesame seed crust • 12" | 14" | 16"

Housemade ranch, hot chicken, bacon, jalapeno, cheese • 12" | 14" | 16"

Black garlic, seasonal fruit, gorgonzola, mozzarella, fresh basil, prosciutto, EVOO • 12" | 14" | 16"

Peanut butter sauce, bacon, jam, mozzarella, provolone, jalapeno • 12" | 14" | 16"

Fried chicken, broccoli, pineapple, garlic, EVOO, general Tso's sauce, mozzarella • 12" | 14" | 16"

Mustard wine sauce, pulled pork, ham, pickle, swiss, mozzarella • 12" | 14" | 16"

Fried chicken, Belgian waffle, fruited maple, mozzarella • 12" | 14" | 16"

EVOO, garlic, caramelized onion, parmesan, cremini, arugula, brie, balsamic reduction • 12" | 14" | 16"

Garlic, parmesan, mozzarella, chicken, tikka masala sauce, cilantro • 12" | 14" | 16"

Served with housemade herb butter, garlic & nutritional yeast.

Bite sized butter pretzels served with black truffle honey mustard.

Served with black truffle honey mustard, ketchup.

Served with housemade ketchup, chimichuri.

Served with housemade ketchup, chimichuri.

Mixed greens, heart of palm, white balsamic dressing, nutritional yeast.

BBQ, Medium, Hot, or X-tra Hot.

Small 12" | Medium 14" | Large 16"

Vegan Pepperoni, Banana Pepper, Spinach, Jalapeno, Black Olive, Onion, Cremini Mushroom, Pineapple, Green Pepper, Garlic, Kalamata Olive, Corn, Black Garlic, Arugula, Heart of Palm, Artichoke, Pinto Bean | Small | Medium | Large

Vegan cheese, tikka masala sauce, chik'n, garlic, cilantro • 12" | 14" | 16"

Vegan cheese, chik'n, broccoli, pineapple, garlic, general Tso's sauce • 12" | 14" | 16"

Black truffle oil, EVOO, vegan cheese, nutritional yeast, criminis, red onions, garlic • 12" | 14" | 16"

Vegan cheese, EVOO, nutritional yeast, tomato, garlic • 12" | 14" | 16"